Points vs Miles vs Cashback: Which Rewards Are Actually Worth More?

The credit card industry wants you confused about rewards.

Points! Miles! Cash back! Transfer partners! Redemption portals! The complexity is intentional—it obscures value comparisons and makes you feel like you need a PhD in points optimization.

Here's the truth: Most people should just take the cash. Points and miles can be worth more, but only if you're willing to invest time in learning the system and actually use them for specific redemptions.

Let's break down what each reward type is actually worth.

---

The Three Reward Types Explained

Cash Back

What it is: A percentage of your purchase returned as cash.

How you get it: Statement credit, direct deposit, or check.

Value: Fixed. 2% cash back is always worth 2 cents per dollar.

Example:

• Spend $10,000
• Earn 2% cash back
• Receive $200
• Value: $200 (guaranteed)

Points

What it is: A proprietary currency (Chase Ultimate Rewards, Amex Membership Rewards, etc.)

How you use it: Statement credit, travel portal, transfer to airlines/hotels, gift cards.

Value: Variable. Depends entirely on how you redeem.

Example (Chase Ultimate Rewards):

• Spend $10,000 at 2x points
• Earn 20,000 points
• Statement credit value: $200 (1 cent each)
• Travel portal value: $250 (1.25 cents each with Sapphire Preferred)
• Transfer to Hyatt: $300-600+ (1.5-3+ cents each)

Miles

What it is: Airline or hotel loyalty currency (Delta SkyMiles, United MileagePlus, Marriott Bonvoy, etc.)

How you use it: Flights, hotel stays, upgrades, experiences.

Value: Highly variable. Depends on redemption, availability, and program.

Example (Delta SkyMiles):

• Earn 20,000 miles
• Domestic economy flight: ~$150 value (0.75 cents each)
• International business class: ~$500 value (2.5 cents each)
• Cash equivalent at worst: ~$100 (0.5 cents each)

---

Actual Value Comparison

Cash Back Value: Fixed

Certainty: 100%. You always know what you're getting.

Points Value: Variable

Chase Ultimate Rewards

Amex Membership Rewards

Capital One Miles

Airline Miles Value: Highly Variable

---

When Each Type Makes Sense

Choose Cash Back If:

• You don't travel frequently (less than 2-3 flights/year)
• You value simplicity over optimization
• You'd rather have flexibility
• You don't want to learn point strategies
• You'd use points for statement credits anyway
• You need the money for business expenses

The case for cashback: A 2% cash back card gives you $200 per $10,000 spent. You can use that $200 for anything. No expiration, no devaluation, no complexity.

Choose Points If:

• You travel 4+ times per year
• You're willing to learn transfer partners
• You value premium travel experiences
• You have flexibility in travel dates
• You want aspirational redemptions (business class, luxury hotels)
• You have specific redemption goals

The case for points: Transfer to the right partner at the right time, and 20,000 points becomes a $600 flight. But this requires knowledge, flexibility, and effort.

Choose Miles If:

• You're loyal to one airline
• You fly the same routes frequently
• You want elite status benefits
• You book award flights regularly
• You understand the specific program's value

The case for miles: If you fly Delta 20 times a year, earning SkyMiles makes sense—you get elite status, better redemptions, and know the program.

---

The Hidden Costs of Points and Miles

Devaluation

Point and mile values decrease over time. Airlines and hotels regularly:

• Increase award prices
• Remove availability
• Change redemption charts

Cash back doesn't devalue. $200 is always $200.

Complexity Cost

Learning to maximize points takes time:

• Understanding transfer partners
• Finding availability
• Knowing redemption sweet spots
• Tracking program changes

If your time is worth money, factor in the hours spent optimizing.

Opportunity Cost

Points sitting unused are worth nothing. If you earn 100,000 points but never use them, their value is $0.

Cash back can be:

• Invested
• Used for business
• Spent immediately

Breakage

A significant percentage of points and miles are never redeemed. Credit card companies count on this. If you're not actively using rewards, cash back ensures you don't leave value on the table.

---

Real-World Scenarios

Scenario 1: Small Business Owner, $100K Annual Spend

Cash back approach (2%):

• Annual rewards: $2,000 cash
• Value: $2,000 (certain)

Points approach (2x points):

• Annual rewards: 200,000 points
• Minimum value (statement credit): $2,000
• Maximum value (optimal redemptions): $4,000-6,000
• Realistic value: $2,500-3,000 (if you optimize)

Verdict: Points win IF you travel and optimize. Cash back wins for simplicity.

Scenario 2: Occasional Traveler, $50K Annual Spend

Cash back (2%):

• Annual rewards: $1,000 cash

Points (2x):

• Annual rewards: 100,000 points
• Realistic redemptions: $1,200-1,500

Verdict: Points marginally better, but extra effort may not be worth $200-500 difference.

Scenario 3: Frequent Business Traveler, $200K Annual Spend

Cash back (2%):

• Annual rewards: $4,000 cash

Points (2x):

• Annual rewards: 400,000 points
• Business class flights: $8,000-16,000 value
• Hotel stays: Additional value

Verdict: Points significantly better for frequent travelers.

---

The Hybrid Strategy

You don't have to choose just one. Optimize by using multiple reward types.

The Recommended Stack

1. Cash back card for everyday spending

   • 2% on everything you don't optimize
   • Guaranteed value, no expiration

2. Points card for travel booking

   • Use for flights, hotels when points value exceeds cash
   • Transfer to partners for big redemptions

3. Category cards for bonus spending

   • 5% at office stores (Chase Ink Cash)
   • 4% on advertising (Amex Gold)
   • Matches category to best reward

When to Use Each

---

How to Calculate Your True Value

Step 1: Track Your Spending

Know where your money goes:

• Office supplies: $X/month
• Travel: $X/month
• Advertising: $X/month
• General expenses: $X/month

Step 2: Calculate Cash Back Value

Sum all spending × best available cash back rates.

Example:

• $50,000 spend × 2% = $1,000

Step 3: Calculate Points Value (Realistically)

Sum all spending × earn rate × realistic redemption value.

Example:

• $50,000 spend × 2x = 100,000 points
• Realistic redemption: 1.3¢/point
• Value: $1,300

Step 4: Compare

If points value > cash back value AND you'll actually redeem optimally, choose points. Otherwise, choose cash back.

---

Common Mistakes

Mistake 1: Hoarding Points

Points aren't investments. They devalue over time. Use them.

Mistake 2: Overvaluing Points

Counting points at 2¢ each when you'll actually use them for statement credits at 0.6¢.

Mistake 3: Ignoring Time Cost

Spending 5 hours to find an award flight that saves $200 means you're valuing your time at $40/hour.

Mistake 4: Not Redeeming

The best value is the value you actually capture. Unredeemed rewards are worthless.

Mistake 5: Wrong Card for Your Spend

Earning airline miles when you never fly is pointless. Match rewards to how you actually spend and travel.

---

Recommendation by Profile

"I just want simplicity"

Get: Capital One Spark Cash Plus (2% unlimited) or Amex Blue Business Cash (2% up to $50K)

No thinking required. Pure cash back.

"I travel 4+ times per year for business"

Get: Chase Ink Preferred + Amex Gold

Earn transferable points. Use for flights and hotels.

"I want to maximize every dollar"

Get: Category card stack (Ink Cash, Amex Gold, etc.) + cash back base card

Match cards to spending categories. Requires tracking but maximizes returns.

"I'm loyal to one airline"

Get: That airline's co-branded card

Earn status, benefits, and miles in a program you'll use.

---

Next Steps

Stop overthinking rewards. Ask yourself:

1. How much do I travel?
2. Do I want to spend time optimizing?
3. Will I actually redeem points for travel?

If you travel frequently and will optimize: points. If you want simplicity and flexibility: cash back. If you're loyal to one program: miles.

For most business owners, 2% cash back beats 1.5x points that sit unredeemed. The best reward is the one you use.

---

Need help building your rewards strategy? Freedom Consulting helps business owners maximize credit card rewards. Book a free consultation to optimize your spending.

---

Related: Business Cashback Mastery | Best Business Cashback Cards

Disclaimer: Reward values change. Calculate based on current redemption options.

---

Continue Learning

This article is part of our Business Cashback Mastery: The Complete Guide to 2-5% Back on Everything guide series.

Related articles in this series:

• Best Business Cashback Cards 2025: Ranked by Category
• Credit Card Sign-Up Bonus Strategy: How to Earn $5,000+ in First Year
• Credit Card Reward Programs: Complete Guide to Points and Perks